Navigating Trials for Car Accident Cases

The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C. • April 8, 2024

Navigating the aftermath of a car accident can be an overwhelming process, especially when the path to compensation for your injuries and losses isn’t straightforward. While many car accident cases are settled outside of court, there are circumstances where taking your case to trial is the best or only option. Mort Shuman, a distinguished personal injury lawyer based in Framingham, MA, specializes in guiding clients through the intricacies of car accident cases, including when a trial becomes necessary. Here’s a comprehensive look at the critical factors that might lead your car accident case to court.

Understanding the Settlement Process

The Role of Insurance Companies


Most car accident claims begin with negotiations with the insurance company of the party at fault. However, insurance companies are in the business of minimizing payouts. When an insurance company’s settlement offer does not cover your medical bills, lost wages, and other damages, it may be time to consider taking your case to trial.


When Settlement Offers Fall Short


An experienced personal injury lawyer like Mort Shuman can help assess the fairness of a settlement offer. Suppose negotiations reach a standstill or the insurance company refuses to offer a reasonable settlement. In that case, your attorney may advise that filing a lawsuit is the next step.

Factors Leading to Trial

Disputed Liability


One of the most common reasons a car accident case goes to trial is disputed liability. If the at-fault party denies responsibility for the accident, proving fault in court may be necessary. This requires a thorough investigation, evidence collection, and expert testimony—areas where Mort Shuman’s expertise shines.


Severe Injuries and Compensation


Cases involving severe injuries often result in higher compensation amounts, which insurance companies may resist paying. When the compensation required to cover long-term medical care, rehabilitation, and lost earning capacity exceeds the insurance company’s offer, a trial might be the only avenue to secure the compensation you deserve.


Non-economic Damages


Non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life, can be challenging to quantify. Insurance companies often undervalue these damages. A trial allows your attorney to present a comprehensive case to a jury, highlighting the accident’s total impact on your life.

The Trial Process

Expert Legal Representation


Having a skilled attorney like Mort Shuman by your side is crucial when taking your case to trial. An attorney with experience in car accident cases will be adept at navigating court procedures, presenting evidence, and arguing your case compellingly before a judge and jury.


Gathering Evidence


The success of a trial heavily relies on the strength of the evidence presented. This includes accident reports, medical records, eyewitness testimony, and expert opinions. Mort Shuman’s legal team compiles and presents evidence that effectively supports your claim.


The Importance of Testimony


Personal testimony about the accident’s impact on your life is a powerful component of your case. Your attorney will prepare you to share your story in a compelling and legally relevant way, emphasizing the necessity of the compensation you seek.

Why Choose Mort Shuman?

Mort Shuman combines in-depth knowledge of Massachusetts’ personal injury law with a compassionate approach to representation. Understanding that each case is unique, he provides personalized legal strategies to achieve the best possible outcome, whether through settlement or trial.


While the goal is always to settle a car accident claim reasonably and efficiently, some cases inevitably require the scrutiny of a trial. In such instances, having an experienced personal injury lawyer like Mort Shuman can make all the difference in achieving a favorable outcome. If you’re in Framingham, MA, considering taking your car accident case to court, contact Mort Shuman for expert legal guidance and advocacy.

Lawyer in suit writing, with scales of justice and gavel on desk.

Personal Injury Attorney in Framingham You Can Trust

By The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C. • November 4, 2025
Seeking out a personal injury lawyer after an accident can be overwhelming. With so many options, you may not know who to trust.  The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C.  , has been serving the Framingham, MA, community for over sixty years. When you need an attorney,  The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C.  has the record to prove our commitment.
Man injured at work, aided by a colleague.

Machinery-Related Injuries: Who’s at Fault When Equipment Fails?

By The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C. • October 7, 2025
Workplaces throughout Massachusetts rely on heavy machinery and equipment to operate efficiently. In construction sites, factories, warehouses, and beyond, employees and contractors rely on machines every day to perform critical tasks. When equipment fails or malfunctions, the consequences can be devastating. Severe injuries, long recoveries, and lost wages are too common. After an accident, important questions can arise about who is legally responsible for injuries.
Motorcycle on its side in road, damaged.

Who’s Liable in an Electric Scooter Accident in Natick, MA?

By The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C. • September 9, 2025
Electric scooters are becoming more and more common on the streets of Natick, MA, offering a convenient and eco-friendly way to travel short distances. As their popularity grows, so do questions about liability in the event of an accident. Unlike cars and motorcycles, e-scooters are not considered motor vehicles in Massachusetts. That distinction changes how accident claims are handled and who may be liable.
Person wearing wrist device gestures over document on table.

Denied Workers’ Compensation Claims: What to Do Next

By The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C. • August 8, 2025
If you’ve been injured at work and your workers’ compensation claim was denied, don’t panic–you still have options. Denials are more common than you might think, and with the best legal support, you may still receive the benefits you’re entitled to. At  The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C.  , we help injured Massachusetts workers fight for compensation through the appeals process.
Angry brown and black dog baring teeth, chained outside in the snow.

Can You File a Claim if a Dog Injures You Without Biting?

By The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C. • July 8, 2025
When most people think of dog-related injuries, they immediately picture dog bites–but there are other ways dogs can cause harm. In Massachusetts, you can pursue a personal injury claim even if a dog injures you without biting. At  The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C.  , we help clients throughout Framingham, Natick, Marlborough, and Milford understand their rights when it comes to dog-related injuries.
Two people tending to a person on the ground, wearing a neck brace, mask, and construction vest.

Construction Site Accidents: Protecting Workers in Massachusetts

By The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C. • June 6, 2025
Construction sites are among the most hazardous workplaces in Massachusetts. From falling objects to faulty equipment, workers face risks every day. When safety measures fail or negligence causes injury, the results can be life-changing or even fatal. At  The Law Offices of Morton J. Shuman, P.C.  , we help injured workers and their families understand their rights and pursue justice.